The Charm of Nut Butters with Oil on Top: Embrace, Mix, and Enjoy


The world of nut butters is a fascinating one, filled with creamy delights and spreadable wonders. But what's the deal with that layer of oil on top? In this blog post, we'll dive into the charm of nut butters with oil separation. Discover why they're worth your attention and learn how to master the art of mixing it all back in for a delectable nutty experience.

Benefits of Nut Butters with Oil on Top:

  1. Natural Goodness: Nut butters with oil separation often boast a minimal ingredient list, free from unnecessary additives. By choosing these varieties, you're opting for a more natural and wholesome product, letting the true flavor of the nuts shine through.
  1. Freshness Assurance: The presence of oil on top is actually a sign of freshness. It indicates that the nut butter hasn't been overly processed to prevent separation. So, when you see that oil layer, rest assured that you're indulging in a freshly made spread, bursting with quality and flavor.
  1. Customizable Texture: One of the perks of mixing in the oil yourself is the ability to customize the texture to suit your preferences. Whether you enjoy a smooth, creamy consistency or prefer a bit of chunkiness, you have the power to create the perfect spread by incorporating the oil as desired.

How to Mix the Oil Back In:

  1. Equip Yourself: Before we embark on our mixing adventure, gather a clean utensil like a spoon or butter knife, and of course, a jar of nut butter with that tempting layer of oil on top.
  2. Assess the Situation: Give the jar a quick visual inspection. If you notice any signs of spoilage, such as an off smell or mold, it's best to discard the nut butter. But if everything looks and smells good, proceed to the next step.
  3. The Mixing Magic Begins: Open the jar and take in the enticing aroma of freshly ground nuts. Now, insert your utensil into the jar, reaching down to the bottom. Start stirring, making sure to incorporate the oil from the top all the way down to the bottom of the jar. Be thorough, ensuring a well-blended and consistent texture.
  4. Mix Until Perfect: Continue stirring until the oil is fully incorporated, and the nut butter achieves a uniform consistency. This may take a few minutes, depending on the thickness of the spread. Exercise patience, my nut butter enthusiast, for the end result will be worth it.
  5. Store and Savor: Once you've achieved nut butter blending excellence, tightly close the jar and store it in a cool, dry place. Proper storage will help minimize further oil separation. Now, it's time to spread, dip, or spoon your way into nutty bliss.


Nut butters with oil on top possess a unique charm, signaling natural goodness and freshness. By embracing the oil separation and skillfully mixing it back in, you unlock the ability to customize the texture and create a spread that perfectly suits your taste buds. So, the next time you encounter that layer of oil atop your Hank's spread, embrace the opportunity to mix, savor, and enjoy a truly delightful nutty experience.

Back to blog
1 of 2